
When Occupy Vancouver started, there was a lot of hope… we were angry that we live in a broken system who has left us behind… a system to which we remain powerless, nameless and voiceless…
And for a day or two we found ourselves in others… through solidarity, through open communication… we became sisters and brothers in our struggles… we fed each other, we kept each other warm during cold nights, we kept each other motivated and inspired…
As of last night, what I saw was merely a tent city… with large structures that concealed… large structures… too large to be considered a symbolic occupation… the rise of the tent city…
I saw in the last couple of days that the growth and expansion of tent city has taken a priority I personally never expected… the discussions have died down… the general assemblies no longer the force that drives the movement… I began to wonder whether Occupy Vancouver with its physical expansion was only a process of overstaying our welcome…
Personally I did not participate in many general assemblies… from the onset, the general assemblies seem dominated by few voices, known voices and faces… at every assembly, there were still silent voices, nameless faces… These meetings, in my perspective, were inert at points of procedural topics rather than an open discussion on why we were there to begin with…
I see this movement from where I stand now… with the knowledge I have acquired from working within… And I personally think that Occupy Vancouver has lost it’s very essence.
The movement needs focus. The focus is to change our society for the better through reasonable and creative strategies of solidarity not only with each other here, but also our national network of occupy Canada… in order to do so we must gain the trust and respect of the public, who occupiers call part and parcel of the 99%.
I ask, what does blocking a busy intersection during rush hour traffic achieve? What does the disruption of a public Mayoral debate achieve? I would say they both result on a general sense of wary and caution on how the true 99% view and make sense of Occupy Vancouver. These are actions that lack a sense of strategic engagement… we can do better… and in order to win, we must do better…
What I would suggest now is for Occupy Vancouver to stop all committee meetings and all infighting, and take a day to reflect… We have many pressing real concrete issues all Canadians should be addressing as a nation. We have forgotten the very essence of why we gathered together…
I propose a strategic remodeling of Occupy Vancouver, and for this matter, a national united Occupy Canada. A coordinated strategy to organize around issues. I hope you would take the time to read through this and adapt it as you see fit.
I think we can assume that a large group faces difficulties reaching consensus. However we should also consider that not everyone is always interested in the same topics/issues. Breaking up the general assembly into Specific Issue Committees would allow those who are interested and those who are experts in the field to participate in the relevant discussions and hopefully reach a consensus on a proposal on potential campaign ideas to tackle these issues.
I propose a strategy based movement:
I believe the wish for change is strong, and that once we organize the structure within which we can address real issues affecting Canadians, we will not only be able to achieve change through creative and reasonable strategies but also gain the support and alliance of those who comprise the true 99% of our society.
While these are well thought out suggestions, may I suggest that change is not going to be brought about in Occupy Vancouver by people who’ve publicly LEFT Occupy Vancouver. If you’re committed to change, why don’t you take advantage of the sometimes ad hoc nature of the GA and make the proposal in person? You can’t do it if you refuse to participate.
I agree that it’s lost its focus, and have my own ideas about whether or not that’s an accident, but I know that if I want to bring about the changes I want to see, in Occupy Vancouver or anywhere else, I need to get my ass in the game.
I’ve a great deal of respect for what you’ve done (for one thing, you’re FAR more competent and effective than whoever’s running their twitter stream, and now they have sub-streams with 50 followers!!!) and I think the movement is poorer without you and you are poorer without the movement.
Be the change.
I did participate and proposed issue based GAs. i cannot force it upon it… i think the movement needs a better structure.
We have a #OccupyCanada chat
Twitter bot caught your tweet about this which brought me here
Quick Chat with this link http://tinyurl.com/occupycan
Otherwise: irc.indymedia.org #OccupyCanada
I agree with just about everything you say Min!
?? i cant get in
Should just have to click ‘Chat’ thats Indymedia’s web based thing. There is also Mibbit… http://tinyurl.com/6cu5ago – same deal just different client.
dammit thats for #OccupyVancouver
This is the Mibbit one for #OccupyCanada http://tinyurl.com/6f5a32u
Good ideas on strategy and proceeding, Min,… as for something of consiquence What would you think of putting “My Suggestion”: … on the discussion table,(I own this IP and have at my disposal) http://www.goodsenserules.com/id26.html
do you think it would be of interest?
I disagree with the condesending statement of media, that there is no focus, which we have assumed to follow and thus allowed that perception to flourish. It may be early in the process of making people aware that what this movement is trying to accomplish????? Is confirm and raise awareness throughout the society, that it is not what we do, that is wrong! It is our way of thinking, that is wrong!
What is wrong?
We have allowed ourselves stray away from compassionate consideration of others in our actions in pursuit of financial satisfaction. What is wrong with having a steady income to purchase what is available? (toys,electronics, nice house, car, etc) Nothing in principle. However, along the way of the pursuit we have lost the basic concept of how much is enough, or not enough! We have allowed business, our representatives, and those whome have chosen, or have assumed they have the inclination and drive, to represent us/themselves, while losing the premise of limitations. Those are moral issues we have assumed will prevail with us, and have instead become waveriders, without true committment to each other. This movement is not a hippie generation, but very close in raising awareness…….And the rest will be history that the media will thrash as they happilly look for substance they themselves cannot offer.
Pingback: Min Reyes » Archive » One rumour… one blogpost…
Pingback: #VanElxn: Overcoming the left’s ambivalent relationship with power « David P Ball
Pingback: One rumour… one blogpost… |
Pingback: A Message To Occupy: It’s Time To Move Forward | NEWS JUNKIE POST
Pingback: » Archive » OCCUPIERS! Occupy Reification